Why Celebrating Halloween Doesn’t Make Me A Bad Indian

Tangy Tuesday Picks – 3 November, 2015

Happy Halloween

I first read about Halloween in a story-book I got for my fourteenth birthday. It piqued my interest – you know, all those goodies and chocolates people have ready for you, the fun costumes you get to dress up in, and the glowing jack-o’-lantern at your doorstep. I especially loved the lantern because it gleamed so. (Erm, actually, it was the best possible use I could think for a vegetable I detest.)

Eventually, Mom and I decided to make an art project out of it and we have celebrated Halloween ever since. We make ourselves a lantern and light it when it gets dark, much to the amusement of the household cats and the neighbours. We also put up a trick-or-treat goodies bag and collect chocolates from the family. The year before last, we even made a paper cut-out of a human skeleton – complete with limbs and bones. Now, why I am talking about all this is some of the harsh and, in my opinion, uncalled for, social sentiment I have come across about “Indians celebrating Halloween”. Apparently, celebrating Halloween in India makes you a bad Indian because we have “enough horrors” already.

First things first, I don’t like it when people miss out on qualifiers – “everyone” as opposed to “some”, for instance. All pigs are unclean? No, one of my friends has a pet pig and she’s super clean. Along the same lines, if “some” people have ugly Halloween bashes and create a ruckus, don’t assume “all” Indians do so. And hey, which festival in India is completely peaceful and devoutly observed? I see enough drunk people on Diwali, lecherous folk during Navratri, and plenty of questionable parties happening during Christmas.

There are open letters doing the rounds on the Internet that rubbish the idea of importing a new festival to India, especially one where people dress up in fancy costumes and put on face paint. Well, while I am not particularly fond of some of the more newfangled celebrations in India, I don’t see what’s wrong with face paint. Pray, aren’t there plenty of enthusiastic moms alwaysΒ willing to take on Fancy Dress competitions by storm?

I agree with one popular argument – how asking your kids to trick-or-treat with strangers can be dangerous. Yes, it can be. But there are workarounds! You could get your kids to keep to your residential society or even your household. Daddy and Mummy’s gifts are exciting enough! And while the crime rate in India is the subject of critical media attention, parents elsewhere are also worried about their kids’ safety when dealing with strangers. This may well be a creative way to teach them more about it.

My biggest concern with the Halloween backlash is the patronizing tone about celebrating a “festival of horror” in a country that already has too much of it. What is with this ugly viewpoint on India, all the time? Should we perhaps ban all horror cinema from playing in Indian multiplexes, or get tarot card readers to shut up about the dark future, or get children to stop reading Goosebumps? If you’re afraid celebrating Halloween will lead to third-grade Bollywood movies, horrible music videos and irritating social media trends, breathe easy. Why? Well, all of that needs no causal agent. We have become brilliant with producing jarring music and inferior films. Blaming Halloween for the mediocrity is stretching it too far.

Why do I make such a big deal about Halloween? For Harry Potter and the delicious spread in the Great Hall. For my beautiful story-book. For the one time in the year when I can get R to eat some pumpkin. So, when night-time arrives on Oct 31, I am going to have my jack-o’-lantern ready and dig into Halloween-special food. I may even watch a horror film and stay up for the rest of the night. And no, I won’t be adding to the “horror” so prevalent in our country. I will simply be doing what makes Mom and me happy.

To those of you celebrating tomorrow – Happy Halloween!


18 thoughts on “Why Celebrating Halloween Doesn’t Make Me A Bad Indian

  1. Ah well. Personally, we make a big deal of everything. Social media has given a vent out opportunity to all and sundry so outrage is the way to go for EVERYTHING.
    We had trick or treating in our community and I feel horrible that I couldn’t send Zo cos it clashed with another school event. Also we had dandiya the same night. Folks participated in EVERYTHING. For me, having fun is of paramount importance, and NO, complete knowledge of the history is not a must-have, good-to-have at most.

    • Cheers to that! I agree with you on how people now use social media to express outrage over everything, irrespective of whether or not this is justified. This outrage is so often over really trivial issues that I feel the best course of action is to try and be indifferent.

      Looks like fun times are on at your place! πŸ™‚ Have a super festive season!

  2. Happy Halloween. Oh! This bullshit about Videshi taakat and all that bull crap. Some people need to get a life. As if what’s happening is nothing less than horror with hatred spawning the way.

  3. Happy Halloween πŸ™‚
    Nice thoughts.
    Not celebrating Halloween as we already have so many festivals in Odisha, India. One festival over means it is time for another! Just celebrated Kumar Purnima & right now Gajalakshmi Puja is on for 11 days. Pretty pandals here. That’s the beauty of incredible India.

    • Wow, it sounds like a gloriously festive time! I am gearing up for Diwali. πŸ˜€
      I love it when there are Puja pandals around town – makes everything so much brighter. Have a happy month ahead Anita. ❀

  4. The other article that you mention continually has way more substance than yours. An ugly viewpoint of India, why? Because it’s undeniable and right in our faces.
    Do you know most people celebrating Halloween don’t even know the mythology behind it?
    I like your pig analogy, it makes sense. However, it’s sheep mentality, here in India. And excuse me, fancy dress competitions are WAY different from Halloween, when juxtaposed.
    You can celebrate it all you want and so can hundreds of people. But respecting a festival and then enjoying it makes more sense, I believe.

    • Hey there!
      Going by how you started off the comment, I presume you too have come across such negative Halloween sentiment. I’d beg to differ on the “ugly Indian viewpoint”, if you please. There is enough good still happening in our country and I don’t think celebrating a harmless festival takes away from it at all.
      I agree with you about respecting a festival. But I am afraid there are some people who don’t know the story behind our good old Indian festivals either. The same standard is projected onto a foreign festival. But this is not a commentary on Indian vs. foreign festivity, but rather a commentary on some people in general. Dislike it as we may, these some people will continue to be casual and believe in ugly celebrations.
      Thank you for liking the pig analogy. But your labelling it as “sheep mentality” indicates you didn’t get the gist. There are sheep in India, but there also are those clean pigs, you see?
      As for fancy dress competitions, I didn’t intend to term them synonymous to Halloween. My objection was with the criticism of face paint and costumes – which I personally don’t see anything wrong about.

      Thank you for dropping by.

  5. We love to celebrate Halloween around here too. What’s the harm? The kids have so much fun, I do accompany them when they are trick or treating though just to make sure their high spirits don’t land them into trouble. It’s a nice walk for me as well πŸ™‚

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s